Why a soil fertility study is not a calculator estimate
Short answer: Online estimates for soil fertility or Section 180 vary because they are not a study of your tract. They rest on assumptions rather than on samples taken at purchase. DeepYield does not publish a calculator or an estimate tool, and an estimate is not a promised tax result. For fertilizer and lime a farming business buys for land used in farming, Section 180 may apply depending on your facts.
1. Why online estimates vary
An online estimate has to fill in facts it has not measured. Different tools make different assumptions about the land, about how it is used, and about nutrient levels. Change those assumptions, and the estimate changes, even when no one has sampled the tract.
That is why two estimates can disagree. The difference is not proof that either one has documented the purchase. It is a sign that the estimate was built from inputs the tool did not measure at the land.
2. What a study needs
A soil fertility study has to start from the tract itself. DeepYield does not use soil sample reports a client brings. The useful window is before any lime or fertilizer is applied to the new ground, so a study can document what was on hand at purchase rather than what is applied later.
DeepYield measures nutrient levels at acquisition against a baseline for the agricultural use, drawn from university research, and values any excess using USDA data, so you and your tax professional have a documented allocation to consider.
Those steps depend on the agricultural use on the land. An irrigated crop field and a range tract are not measured against the same baseline. The written report is for you and your tax professional. The study is not a promised tax result, and it is not an online estimate with the same label.
3. What an estimate cannot do
An estimate cannot document what was on hand at purchase. It cannot take the place of a study, and it cannot tell you whether you are engaged in the business of farming or whether the land is used in farming. Those are Code conditions, and they are questions for you and a qualified tax professional.
4. The settled Section 180 path
A taxpayer engaged in the business of farming may elect under Internal Revenue Code §180 to deduct, in the year paid or incurred, amounts spent for fertilizer, lime, ground limestone, marl, or other materials that enrich, neutralize, or condition land used in farming, and the cost of applying them. The election applies only to that year, and generally cannot be revoked without IRS consent. It applies to the farmer’s own purchases of those materials for land already used in farming, not automatically to fertility that came with the land.
A person who farms for recreation or pleasure rather than for profit is not engaged in the business of farming. A cash-rent landlord is engaged in the business of farming only if they participate to a material extent in the operation or management of the farm.
5. Next step
Fertility already in the soil when the land was bought is not a settled current Section 180 deduction. Any recovery is unsettled, depends on your facts, and is a decision for you and a qualified tax professional. DeepYield does not promise a deduction.
The useful window is before any lime or fertilizer is applied to the new ground. Book a short soil-study fit call at https://deepyield.com/soil-study. The call is to see whether a soil fertility study may help you and your tax professional document nutrients on hand at purchase.
A free two-year look-back is also available at go.deepyield.com/two-year-lookback.
Frequently asked questions
Can I use an online calculator instead of a soil fertility study?
No. An online estimate is not a measurement of your tract. It is not a substitute for a soil fertility study, and it is not a promised tax result. DeepYield does not publish a calculator or an estimate tool.
Why do online estimates vary?
Online estimates rest on different assumptions about the land, its uses, and nutrient levels. Those assumptions are not samples taken at your purchase, and they are not a study of the same tract. Two estimates can differ for that reason alone, without either one being a documented allocation for you and your tax professional.
Is an online estimate a Section 180 deduction?
No. An estimate is not a deduction and is not a promised tax result. Fertility already in the soil when the land was bought is not a settled current Section 180 deduction. Any recovery is unsettled, depends on your facts, and is a decision for you and a qualified tax professional. DeepYield does not promise a deduction.
Written by DeepYield.
Sources
- 26 U.S.C. §180, Expenditures by farmers for fertilizer, etc. (GovInfo, United States Code, 2024 edition; cite of record): https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2024-title26/html/USCODE-2024-title26-subtitleA-chap1-subchapB-partVI-sec180.htm
- Treas. Reg. §1.180-1, Expenditures by farmers for fertilizer, etc. (T.D. 6548). Cite of record: GovInfo, Code of Federal Regulations, title 26, volume 4, revised as of April 1, 2025: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2025-title26-vol4/pdf/CFR-2025-title26-vol4-sec1-180-1.pdf
- Treas. Reg. §1.175-3, Definition of the business of farming (T.D. 6649). Cite of record: GovInfo, Code of Federal Regulations, title 26, volume 4, revised as of April 1, 2025: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2025-title26-vol4/pdf/CFR-2025-title26-vol4-sec1-175-3.pdf
