A soil fertility study and a farmland appraisal answer different questions
Short answer: A farmland appraisal and a soil fertility study answer different questions. An appraisal is an opinion of the value of the property. A soil fertility study measures nutrient levels at acquisition against a baseline for the agricultural use and values any excess using USDA data. A soil fertility study is not an appraisal of the land, and an appraisal is not a soil fertility study. Fertility already in the soil when the land was bought is not a settled current Section 180 deduction. For fertilizer, lime, or similar materials a farming business buys for land used in farming, Section 180 may apply depending on your facts.
1. The federal rule
A taxpayer engaged in the business of farming may elect under Internal Revenue Code §180 to deduct, in the year paid or incurred, amounts spent for fertilizer, lime, ground limestone, marl, or other materials that enrich, neutralize, or condition land used in farming, and the cost of applying them. The election applies only to that year, and generally cannot be revoked without IRS consent. It applies to the farmer’s own purchases of those materials for land already used in farming, not automatically to fertility that came with the land.
A person who farms for recreation or pleasure rather than for profit is not engaged in the business of farming. A cash-rent landlord is engaged in the business of farming only if they participate to a material extent in the operation or management of the farm.
2. What each one estimates
An appraisal of farmland is an opinion of the value of the property, generally the land and what is on it taken together, at a point in time. A soil fertility study looks at one part of the picture: nutrient levels in the soil at acquisition.
DeepYield measures nutrient levels at acquisition against a baseline for the agricultural use, drawn from university research, and values any excess using USDA data, so you and your tax professional have a documented allocation to consider.
How the baseline is set, and how excess is valued, is explained in How a soil fertility baseline is set, and how excess is valued. The valuation step is covered in USDA data and valuing excess soil nutrients at acquisition.
3. Why one does not replace the other
A soil fertility study is not an opinion of the value of the land, the buildings, or the farm. An appraisal is not a measurement of nutrient levels against a baseline for the agricultural use. Neither one sets a tax result.
Why an online figure is not a study of a particular tract is explained in Why a soil fertility study is not a calculator estimate.
4. Purchase price, allocation, and native nutrients
How a purchase price is allocated among the land, improvements, and anything else is a question for you and a qualified tax professional. An allocation written into a contract is not itself a tax result, as explained in Allocating purchase price to fertility in the contract.
DeepYield does not present native or inherent soil nutrients as deductible. Land itself is not depreciated. That distinction is explained in Land is not depreciated, and DeepYield does not present native soil nutrients as depreciable.
5. Fertility already in the soil
Unexhausted fertilizer acquired with the land is a different situation from fertilizer you buy after the purchase, and from native nutrients.
Some farmland buyers, with a soil study and a purchase-price allocation, treat unexhausted fertilizer acquired with the land as a wasting asset that may be recoverable over time under §167. That treatment is unsettled and aggressive. No statute, regulation, revenue ruling, or court decision authorizes a current §180 deduction for residual fertility acquired with the land. The only IRS written determination on residual fertilizer bought with farmland, a 1991 technical advice memorandum, denied the taxpayer’s amortization claim: the taxpayer had to prove beneficial ownership, that fertilizer applied by the prior owner was present and measurable, and that it was being used up over a defined period, and did not. Whether any recovery is available, under which Code section, and over what period, depends on your facts and is a decision for you and a qualified tax professional. DeepYield does not promise a §180 election or any tax result. If you later sell the land, an amount attributable to fertilizer or lime included in the selling price may be taxed as ordinary income. A deduction that cannot be supported may be disallowed, with interest and penalties.
The settled-versus-unsettled treatment is also explained in Residual fertility acquired with land: what is settled and what is not.
6. The study, and next step
DeepYield does not use soil sample reports a client brings.
DeepYield measures nutrient levels at acquisition against a baseline for the agricultural use, drawn from university research, and values any excess using USDA data, so you and your tax professional have a documented allocation to consider.
The useful window is before any lime or fertilizer is applied to the new ground. Book a short soil-study fit call at https://deepyield.com/soil-study. The call is to see whether a soil fertility study may help you and your tax professional document nutrients on hand at purchase.
A free two-year look-back is also available at go.deepyield.com/two-year-lookback.
Frequently asked questions
Is a soil fertility study the same as a farmland appraisal?
No. An appraisal is an opinion of the value of the property. A soil fertility study measures nutrient levels at acquisition against a baseline for the agricultural use and values any excess using USDA data. A soil fertility study is not an appraisal of the land.
Can an appraisal or a soil fertility study make fertility already in the soil a Section 180 deduction?
Fertility already in the soil when the land was bought is not a settled current Section 180 deduction. Any recovery is unsettled, depends on your facts, and is a decision for you and a qualified tax professional. DeepYield does not promise a deduction. Neither document sets a tax result.
Do I need both an appraisal and a soil fertility study?
They answer different questions. Whether either one fits a particular purchase is a question for you and a qualified tax professional.
Written by DeepYield.
Sources
- 26 U.S.C. §180, Expenditures by farmers for fertilizer, etc. (GovInfo, United States Code, 2024 edition; cite of record): https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2024-title26/html/USCODE-2024-title26-subtitleA-chap1-subchapB-partVI-sec180.htm
- Treas. Reg. §1.180-1, Expenditures by farmers for fertilizer, etc. (T.D. 6548). Cite of record: GovInfo, Code of Federal Regulations, title 26, volume 4, revised as of April 1, 2025: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2025-title26-vol4/pdf/CFR-2025-title26-vol4-sec1-180-1.pdf
- Treas. Reg. §1.175-3, Definition of the business of farming (T.D. 6649). Cite of record: GovInfo, Code of Federal Regulations, title 26, volume 4, revised as of April 1, 2025: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2025-title26-vol4/pdf/CFR-2025-title26-vol4-sec1-175-3.pdf
